MSG: The Melbourne Social Guide

Helping you add flavour to this wonderful city.

Plume Highpoint

with 6 comments

Plume

Shop 6003, Highpoint Shopping Centre
200 Rosamond Rd, Maribyrnong
(03) 9318 6833‎

web
foursquare
urbanspoon

Yum Cha; Mon-Fri 12 noon – 3pm, Sat-Sun 11am-3pm

Located within the busy Knifepoint Highpoint Shopping Complex, Plume has been serving yum cha for many years, and appears to be doing fairly steady trade (though nowhere near as busy as they used to be when we first started going). The family go on a regular basis, but mostly due to its proximity to our grandpa rather than because of the quality or value (which are lacking, or certainly have diminished over the years).

Here are some of the dishes we had;

In order; sticky rice, sesame fried prawns, fried white bait, fried squid tentacles, shark fin dumplings, prawn stuffed tofu, sui mai (pork and prawn dumplings), har gow (prawn dumplings), tripe, har cheung (rice paper roll stuffed with prawns), jar leung (rice paper roll stuffed with fried chinese dough stick, also with vegetables), and gai lan.

The sticky rice was pretty good, as were the fried sesame prawns. The whitebait was ok, but cold by the time we got them, the squid was ok but a little rubbery and oily. The pastry on the shark fin dumplings were too thick and dried, the fillings were so-so. I really enjoyed the silken tofu stuffed with prawn meat, the only downfall to this dish is it says that despite us Chinese people having successfully used chopsticks for eons, maybe it’s time to let go.  The silky soft tofu is very difficult to pick up, and a spoon would have been lovely at the time.

The sui mai and har gow, which are two of my favourite yum cha dishes were disappointing. I judge a yum cha restaurant on their ability to produce these two stalwart (and essential) dishes. The sui mai flavour was not quite there, whereas the har gow pastry was too thick and the flavouring on the prawn only just average. So, big fail in my books.

The tripe was pretty tasty, however was chewy from overcooking, the har cheung was tasty covered in the sweet soy sauce that I love, though took far too long to come. The dough stick wrapped in rice paper is another one of my favourite yum cha dishes and was again a disappointment. This dish is cooked to order (i.e. not available on the carts which roll past), yet it somehow managed to be luke-warm at best by the time it came to our table. This dish is usually served with a peanut sauce and a sticky hoisin sauce, however just came with soy. Though, this dish is not one that is offered at most yum cha’s so I guess points to Plume for having it on their menu despite not doing it well.

I’m not sure how much each costs as when dining with the family it’s always a massive battle to pick up the bill. So much so, we have (and still have) a family feud over who was to pick up a bill (I shit you not!). I do know that Plume’s yum cha is priced on the higher side of normal despite their food being on the lesser side of average.

So it’s no surprise that the following of Plume seems to be dwindling. Years ago, we used to have to fight for a table only to be turned away. Now, and we dined on Chinese New Year, we waltz straight in and there are empty tables. It appears that most in the west are shifting to the much better Gold Leaf in Sunshine.

One gripe I have about yum cha in Australia is the carts. Whilst I love being able to see my food before I eat it, I much prefer the yum cha in Hong Kong; where dishes are made to order. You get a sheet of paper, and tick the dishes you want, which are steamed or fried fresh to order. I hate the fried yum cha food here in Australia, as it is often cold by the time it arrives to your table.

I dream of the days of yum cha a la carte in Melbourne. What ever happened to Duck Duck Goose, which was rumoured to be serving yum cha a la carte? Still waiting

Jess’ Ratings:

Taste: 5/10. It’s ok. It’s doable. Just not great.

Authenticity: 5/10. Well, all the correct dishes were served. Just not served great. What’s authentic? Authentic for Melbourne yum cha? or for Yum cha in Asia? Because correct me if I’m wrong, there isn’t anyone that does yum cha a la carte in Melbourne. So, if little Cantonese women bashing their carts into your chairs yelling out the dishes they have on offer in said cart whilst trying to offload dishes onto your table, and young waiters ignoring you whilst you desperately try to get their attention for more tea is your idea of yum cha in Melbourne, then Plume is authentic as can be.

Value: 4/10. Expensive for average yum cha.

Ambiance: 5/10. Busy.

Service: 4/10. Chinese people are not about the service.

Overall: 5/10. Average. Only if you’re in the area and can’t get into anywhere else.

Written by glutamatejess

March 25, 2010 at 1:50 am

6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Oh! You didn’t enjoy it. We thought that the yum cha is much better than 6 months ago. The century egg congee was super delicious and I raved about it on my blog. I do agree that they are a pricer and will not go near the dinner but I thought the yum cha was pretty ok.

    Still have yet to try Gold leaf though I didn’t like the one in Docklands.

    penny aka jeroxie

    March 25, 2010 at 11:38 pm

    • Really? I think the quality has really subsided over the years.. certainly the patronage has; it used to be impossible to get a table there, it struggled to be half full even when we went on Chinese New Year. I didn’t have the congee.. but as with all yum chas, some dishes are better than others.
      I do like Gold Leaf; better food, better prices..

      glutamatejess

      March 26, 2010 at 11:53 am

  2. All I have to say is: Tai-Pan FTW!

    alexlobov

    March 26, 2010 at 1:57 am

  3. Hah…. I totally get the battle over the bill!

    I like Gold Leaf in Sunshine too, but am usually too lazy to drive out there.

    Agnes

    March 28, 2010 at 1:06 pm

  4. Yum Cha cafe in the city, and Oriental Tea House on Chapel, and yum cha dragon @ docklands all do a la carte, (even while serving on trays at oriental) Pretty sure Mahjong in st kilda is also a la carte. There’s an article written by the age that has reviews on various yum cha restaurants (I googled melbourne’s best yum cha to find it), and it lists who does trolleys, trays and a la carte.

    Leisha

    May 29, 2010 at 2:18 pm

    • That’s very informative, thanks Leisha!

      alexlobov

      May 29, 2010 at 8:13 pm


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: