MSG: The Melbourne Social Guide

Helping you add flavour to this wonderful city.

Mecca Bah

with 9 comments

Mecca Bah
55A NewQuay Promenade
Docklands VIC 3008
Tel: (03) 9642 1300
website
foursquare
urbanspoon
twitter @RiversMelbourne
Mecca Bah on Urbanspoon

Mecca Bah is precisely the type of restaurant that I do not like. You can rightly assume a great deal about this restaurant from its name and location. Firstly, what the hell does ‘Mecca Bah’ even mean? The orientalist averse in me does not appreciate the Meccafication of place names to make them cool. Mecca is Islam’s holiest city, naming your restaurant Mecca will not make it any better. What it will do is make it sound more exotic, oriental and alluring to the resident bourgeoisie. Hooray! And where does the resident bourgeoisie in Melbourne like to play? Well, apart from Crown Casino, we’re talking the Docklands! Which brings me to another point, I hate the Docklands. The place has absolutely no redeeming features that I’ve so far discovered (apart from maybe Bhoj but it isn’t that great). It’s just a collection of ugly residential skyscrapers, shiny metallic and minimalist surfaces, cliched ethnic restaurants like Mecca Bah (and some horrible looking Italian red-check-tablecloth places) and factory outlets. This explains why the place is always empty.

As I was saying, Mecca Bah confirms all your stereotypes and preconceptions. The precise location of the restaurant means that it juts out over the water like some kind of floating dome, it’s decorated in a mixed minimalist style with some of the most cliched faux Middle Eastern adornments imaginable (Turkish tiles, *yawn*) and its menu can be euphemistically described as ‘fusion’, but that’s a term we give innovative and interesting menus, not a hodge podge of bastardised, Westernised menu items seemingly aimed at insular Australians wanting ‘the Middle Eastern’ experience but without all the Islam, potential terrorism and poverty of Melbourne’s Western (and Northern) suburbs.

Speaking of ‘Middle Eastern’, I’ve always been suspicious of restaurants billed exclusively as ‘Middle Eastern cuisine’. What the hell is Middle Eastern cuisine? We’re talking about a disparate geographical region with undefined borders that spans three continents and includes racial varities such as Berbers, Arabs, Kurds, Turks and Arabs, as well as a number of languages and religions. Some of you may know that I blog about Middle Eastern politics elsewhere and lived in the region for a year so I’m kind of fussy. To me, calling cuisine ‘Middle Eastern’ makes about as much as sense as calling it ‘Asian’ or ‘European’.

So what about the food? Well we had three dishes all of which, I suppose, you could classify as mains. They didn’t leave me with a great hankering for more. Disclaimer, this is obviously a negative review but the food wasn’t all that bad, I mean I’ve definitely had worse, but it definitely does not live up to its greatly undeserved reputation.

First up there was the beef tagine (billed as Moroccan) with ‘Ras el Hanout’ spices, dates and raisins ($23.50). Now from the, admittedly, little I know of Moroccan cooking, this isn’t a very good description as it essentially means the best spices a shop has to offer. (The words themselves, in Arabic, mean ‘head of the shop’). It was a soupy concoction with cous cous and, although not altogether unpleasant, it’s not something I would order again. (I can barely remember how it tasted).

We also sampled two of their popular Turkish pizzas (there was a wait to get a table and some people had elected to get these pizzas takeaway and eat them by the water, I have no idea why). I was expecting something like the Lahmajoun available in the Middle East, what’s traditionally known as a Turkish or Levantine pizza, but what I got was something completely different.

Pictured above is the spiced chicken pizza with eggplant, rocket & tahini sauce ($19.80). As you can see, it’s in a very crusty version of Turkish pide with the ingredients stuffed inside. I wasn’t happy with the way the bread was cooked. Turkish pide (or Arabic khubz) is normally baked in a sort of tandoor and while I imagine they may not have had a tandoor on site in the Docklands, they still could’ve done better than this. The ingredients were pleasant, the tahine was essentially yoghurt and the chicken was so lightly spiced that the spices were almost imperceptible but it wasn’t bad.

We also tried the Harissa spiced tomato pizza with haloumi, parsley and roasted eggplant ($17.50). I chose this dish specifically because I love both haloumi and harissa but what I mostly got was… well, tomato. The tomato was supposed to be ‘harissa spiced’ but, again, I could barely taste the harissa. For those uninitiated, harissa is a famously fiery North African chilli paste (I’ve seen arguments between Moroccans and Tunisians about its origins and who does it best so I won’t attribute it to a particular country). These tomatoes were not fiery, they could best be described as tangy. The haloumi was also rubbery and far from fresh. But, again, I guess it didn’t taste too bad. Pictured below.

Perhaps I’m being too harsh on Mecca Bah. Judging from the restaurants popularity, urbanspoon reviews and queues, it’s clearly doing a brisk trade. I guess I’m just a Middle Eastern food snob sensitive to cliched design, inauthentic food and culinary orientalism. Whatever, it’s my review dammit.

Alex’s Ratings:

Taste: 6/10. Given that the dishes were all around $20 and clearly pitched at an uber-Western palate, the food wasn’t altogether unpleasant.

Authenticity: 3/10. Authentic to what? This wasn’t fusion or innovation, it was bastardisation of the lowest order. A few Arabic words in your menu, some tiles and the word ‘Mecca’ in your restaurant name are not enough to be authentic.

Value: 4/10. Why would you pay $20 for a dish when you can eat actually authentic Arab, Turkish or Moroccan food in places like Sydney Road for much less? I suppose the sea view counts for something. Does it?

Ambience: 4/10. And those four points are almost all for the water. And again, outdoor seating (which is where you’d want to sit) is comprised of backless benches. BACKLESS.

Service: 7/10. I’ve seen bad reviews for the service floating around on urbanspoon but it was decent as far as I’m concerned. The place was busy as Hell, the waitresses seemed run off their feet and it took a few requests to get water but they were friendly, attentive and polite. No major complaints there.

Overall: 4/10. While, as I’ve mentioned, the food wasn’t too bad, the biggest reason for this low score comes in the form of a question: why? Why eat here? I can’t see any good reason, apart from perhaps the water, especially given that you have to visit the Docklands.

Advertisements

Written by alexlobov

March 11, 2010 at 4:45 pm

9 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I think I went here years ago when it first opened, and the docklands was a ghost town. Is it still a ghost town? I haven’t been down there since I’ve been back, which makes it about two years since I’ve been. I guess the gravitational pull of Costco hasn’t quite sucked me in yet. But I digress. A lot.

    I remember being rather unimpressed with Mecca Bah even at that stage. I think there was another Mecca restaurant owned by the same people, but I’m not sure if that one closed down. I guess the soul-less environs of the docklands are more conducive to the style of food Mecca Bah produces.

    So I’m curious, because I’m not that much of an expert on the various Middle Eastern cuisines. What are your favourite places around town? I really like Tiba’s in Brunswick for Lebanese, and Zara in Coburg, for Turkish food.

    Billy

    March 12, 2010 at 9:48 am

  2. It’s still a ghost town, there’s a few more people about than there were back in those days but given the scale of the place it’s definitely a failure of sorts. The soulless environs are indeed rather appropriate for Mecca Bah.

    Regarding Middle Eastern food in Melbourne, it’s funny but I actually don’t know a great deal about what’s available. For some reason after I got back I just wrote off the entire Melbourne scene, I think I was subconsciously afraid of disappointment. I mean Tiba’s is good, Abla’s is not bad (from memory though it’s been a while) and Balha’s (Sydney Road) for sweets. Some of my friends have said A1 (Sydney Rd) is good for Lebanese pastries but I haven’t tried it myself. Never heard of Zara.

    alexlobov

    March 12, 2010 at 3:25 pm

  3. I agree – Mecca Bah is a NOT. Might be the best in Docklands but I wouldn’t be travelling to the ghost town to eat there.

    I’ve heard Maha does fab Middle Eastern food (pricey). A1 is FANTASTIC for Middle Eastern pizzas and Hawat on Sydney Rd is good for sweets.

    Jetsetting Joyce

  4. It is hard for me to head to docklands at all. Such a cold and uninviting place.

    penny aka jeroxie

    March 12, 2010 at 9:46 pm

  5. Naww I do love it when we all agree! I need to check these places out, my Melbourne MEastern food phobia needs to die. Has anyone been to Yemeni?

    alexlobov

    March 13, 2010 at 3:14 am

  6. Agreed – this is a NOT for me too. I’ve been to the Mecca Bar twice… First was dinner with two friends. The ambience was enhanced by the soft lights and water. Food was ok but not memorable.

    The second time around another friend wanted to check out this place so we shared a pizza in broad day light. Ambience is no longer so impressive without the soft lighting. The water is was still nice but the ‘bar’ not so much.

    TruffleMe

    April 20, 2010 at 9:14 pm

    • Thanks TruffleMe, it’s always good to get comments in agreement šŸ™‚

      alexlobov

      April 21, 2010 at 3:38 am

  7. Haha, dude, you totally forgot to tag your first paragraph with (not making fun – I love a good arts wanker rant myself).

    I’ve read a fair few reviews that say similar such things about the Docklands eateries: view was great but it was overpriced and the food was nothing special. What the hell are they doing with the Docklands? It’s so…empty (physically and figuratively).

    Keep up the arts wanker ranting, comrade *salutes*

    Gem

    June 17, 2010 at 1:46 am

    • Haha thanks Gem! Yeah I will keep my reviews in my own personal arts wanker style, dammit. But yeah, Docklands = fail. I think I ate at Bhoj once ages ago and didn’t hate it. That’s about it.

      alexlobov

      June 21, 2010 at 6:24 pm


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: